23. Brandon Servania
52. Alonso Coello
14. Mark-Anthony Kaye
9. Charles Sapong
24. Lorenzo Insigne
10. Federico Bernardeschi
28. Raoul Petretta
17. Sigurd Rosted
1. Sean Johnson
2. Matt Hedges
22. Richie Laryea
Tomás Lían Romero Keubler
Ayo Akinola
Shane O'Neill
Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty
A. Mabika
D. Kerr
Adama Diomande
K. Franklin
K. Thompson
20. Richard Ledezma
55. Keaton Parks
35. M. Ilenič
43. Talles Magno
4. Maxime Chanot
22. Kevin O'Toole
1. Luis Barraza
17. Matias Pellegrini
13. Thiago Martins
6. James Sands
10. Santiago Rodriguez
J. Alfaro
Justin Haak
S. Turnbull
Tayvon Gray
Andres Jasson
G. Segal
Alfredo Morales
Braian Cufre
Matt Freese
Toronto FC (4-4-2)
23. Brandon Servania
90'52. Alonso Coello
14. Mark-Anthony Kaye
9. Charles Sapong
90'24. Lorenzo Insigne
10. Federico Bernardeschi
28. Raoul Petretta
17. Sigurd Rosted
1. Sean Johnson
2. Matt Hedges
22. Richie Laryea
Substitutes
Tomás Lían Romero Keubler
Ayo Akinola
Shane O'Neill
Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty
90'A. Mabika
D. Kerr
Adama Diomande
90'K. Franklin
K. Thompson
New York City FC (3-4-3)
20. Richard Ledezma
55. Keaton Parks
55'35. M. Ilenič
43. Talles Magno
4. Maxime Chanot
22. Kevin O'Toole
1. Luis Barraza
17. Matias Pellegrini
55'13. Thiago Martins
6. James Sands
10. Santiago Rodriguez
Substitutes
J. Alfaro
Justin Haak
S. Turnbull
Tayvon Gray
Andres Jasson
55'G. Segal
Alfredo Morales
55'Braian Cufre
Matt Freese