1. Sean Johnson
21. Jonathan Osorio
24. Lorenzo Insigne
28. Raoul Petretta
16. T. Spicer
99. Prince-Osei Owusu
8. Matthew Ben Longstaff
20. Deybi Aldair Flores Flores
7. Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty
17. Sigurd Rosted
15. N. Gomis
L. Gavran
Alonso Coello
Derrick Etienne
K. Franklin
Kevin Long
Aime Mabika
Cassius Mailula
Kosi Thompson
18. R. Celentano
20. Pavel Bucha
15. B. Halsey
22. G. Valenzuela
10. Luciano Acosta
19. Kevin Kelsy
5. Obinna Nwobodo
23. Luca Orellano
32. I. Murphy
21. Matt Miazga
12. Miles Robinson
Alec Kann
Nick Hagglund
Kipp Keller
Sergio Santos
M. Pinto
Yamil Asad
L. Aghedo
S. Jimenez
DeAndre Yedlin
Toronto FC (3-4-2-1)
1. Sean Johnson
21. Jonathan Osorio
70'24. Lorenzo Insigne
28. Raoul Petretta
16. T. Spicer
58'99. Prince-Osei Owusu
8. Matthew Ben Longstaff
20. Deybi Aldair Flores Flores
70'7. Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty
75'17. Sigurd Rosted
15. N. Gomis
Substitutes
L. Gavran
Alonso Coello
70'Derrick Etienne
58'K. Franklin
70'Kevin Long
75'Aime Mabika
Cassius Mailula
Kosi Thompson
FC Cincinnati (3-4-1-2)
18. R. Celentano
20. Pavel Bucha
15. B. Halsey
65'22. G. Valenzuela
72'10. Luciano Acosta
19. Kevin Kelsy
5. Obinna Nwobodo
23. Luca Orellano
88'32. I. Murphy
21. Matt Miazga
12. Miles Robinson
Substitutes
Alec Kann
Nick Hagglund
Kipp Keller
Sergio Santos
72'M. Pinto
Yamil Asad
88'L. Aghedo
S. Jimenez
DeAndre Yedlin
65'