18. Roman Celentano
6. Chidozie Awaziem
12. Miles Robinson
16. Teenage Lingani Hadebe
91. DeAndre Yedlin
27. Yamil Asad
20. Pavel Bucha
5. Obinna Nwobodo
10. Luciano Acosta
23. Luca Orellano
7. Yuya Kubo
Evan Louro
Alvas Elvis Powell
Ian Murphy
Sergio Santos
Corey Baird
Nicholas Gioacchini
Bret Halsey
Gerardo Valenzuela
Kevin Kelsy
49. Matt Freese
24. Tayvon Gray
13. Thiago Martins
5. Birk Risa
22. Kevin O'Toole
55. Keaton Parks
8. Andres Perea
6. James Sands
17. Hannes Wolf
16. Alonso Martinez
10. Santiago Rodriguez
Luis Barraza
Maxi Moralez
Justin Haak
Mitja Ilenic
Monsef Bakrar
Julian Fernandez
Strahinja Tanasijevic
Agustin Ojeda
Jovan Mijatovic
FC Cincinnati (3-4-1-2)
18. Roman Celentano
6. Chidozie Awaziem
12. Miles Robinson
16. Teenage Lingani Hadebe
91. DeAndre Yedlin
46'27. Yamil Asad
90'20. Pavel Bucha
5. Obinna Nwobodo
10. Luciano Acosta
23. Luca Orellano
80'7. Yuya Kubo
89'Substitutes
Evan Louro
Alvas Elvis Powell
46'Ian Murphy
Sergio Santos
80'Corey Baird
90'Nicholas Gioacchini
89'Bret Halsey
Gerardo Valenzuela
Kevin Kelsy
New York City FC (4-3-3)
49. Matt Freese
24. Tayvon Gray
13. Thiago Martins
5. Birk Risa
22. Kevin O'Toole
55. Keaton Parks
76'8. Andres Perea
87'6. James Sands
17. Hannes Wolf
62'16. Alonso Martinez
87'10. Santiago Rodriguez
Substitutes
Luis Barraza
Maxi Moralez
62'Justin Haak
Mitja Ilenic
Monsef Bakrar
87'Julian Fernandez
76'Strahinja Tanasijevic
Agustin Ojeda
Jovan Mijatovic
87'