28. Patrick Schulte
31. Steven Moreira
4. Rudy Camacho
21. Evgen Cheberko
23. Mohamed Farsi
27. Max Arfsten
6. Darlington Nagbe
25. Sean Zawadzki
9. Juan Hernandez
20. Alexandru Matan
17. Christian Ramirez
Derrick Jones
DeJuan Jones
Nicholas Hagen
Evan Bush
Luis Marcelo Herrera
Dylan Chambost
Aziel Jackson
Yaw Yeboah
Jacen Russell-Rowe
31. Carlos Miguel
12. Dylan Nealis
4. Andres Reyes
15. Sean Nealis
47. John Tolkin
17. Cameron Harper
75. Daniel Edelman
20. Felipe Carballo
10. Emil Forsberg
13. Dante Vanzeir
9. Lewis Morgan
Ryan Meara
Dennis Gjengaar
Noah Eile
Peter Stroud
Cory Burke
Elias Manoel
Julian Hall
Wikelman Carmona
Ronald Donkor
Columbus Crew (3-4-2-1)
28. Patrick Schulte
31. Steven Moreira
73'4. Rudy Camacho
84'21. Evgen Cheberko
23. Mohamed Farsi
27. Max Arfsten
72'6. Darlington Nagbe
25. Sean Zawadzki
9. Juan Hernandez
20. Alexandru Matan
59'17. Christian Ramirez
59'Substitutes
Derrick Jones
DeJuan Jones
72'Nicholas Hagen
Evan Bush
Luis Marcelo Herrera
84'Dylan Chambost
73'Aziel Jackson
59'Yaw Yeboah
Jacen Russell-Rowe
59'New York Red Bulls (4-3-1-2)
31. Carlos Miguel
12. Dylan Nealis
88'4. Andres Reyes
15. Sean Nealis
47. John Tolkin
17. Cameron Harper
75. Daniel Edelman
20. Felipe Carballo
88'10. Emil Forsberg
88'13. Dante Vanzeir
74'9. Lewis Morgan
90'Substitutes
Ryan Meara
Dennis Gjengaar
Noah Eile
88'Peter Stroud
88'Cory Burke
Elias Manoel
90'Julian Hall
Wikelman Carmona
74'Ronald Donkor
88'