14. Silvester van der Water
18. Daryl Dike
34. Joseph Dezart
40. Adam Grinwis
9. Chris Mueller
4. Joao Moutinho
2. Ruan
25. Antonio Carlos
6. Robin Jansson
11. Junior Urso
17. Nani
Benji Michel
Andres Perea
Kyle Smith
Greg Ranjitsingh
Rodrigo Adrian Schlegel
Tesho Akindele
Mauricio Pereira
Oriol Rosell
Emmanuel Mas
5. Vito Wormgoor
25. Harrison Afful
6. Darlington Nagbe
7. Pedro Santos
1. Eloy Room
10. Lucas Zelarayan
14. Waylon Francis
20. Alexandru Matan
30. Aboubacar Keita
22. Derrick Etienne
27. Miguel Berry
Bradley Wright-Phillips
Josh Williams
Evan Bush
Erik Hurtado
Grant Lillard
Saad Abdul-Salaam
I. Parente
Orlando City SC (4-4-2)
14. Silvester van der Water
57'18. Daryl Dike
78'34. Joseph Dezart
40. Adam Grinwis
9. Chris Mueller
87'4. Joao Moutinho
2. Ruan
77'25. Antonio Carlos
6. Robin Jansson
11. Junior Urso
17. Nani
57'Substitutes
Benji Michel
57'Andres Perea
Kyle Smith
77'Greg Ranjitsingh
Rodrigo Adrian Schlegel
87'Tesho Akindele
78'Mauricio Pereira
57'Oriol Rosell
Emmanuel Mas
Columbus Crew (4-1-4-1)
5. Vito Wormgoor
25. Harrison Afful
6. Darlington Nagbe
7. Pedro Santos
1. Eloy Room
10. Lucas Zelarayan
14. Waylon Francis
20. Alexandru Matan
65'30. Aboubacar Keita
53'22. Derrick Etienne
72'27. Miguel Berry
72'Substitutes
Bradley Wright-Phillips
72'Josh Williams
53'Evan Bush
Erik Hurtado
65'Grant Lillard
Saad Abdul-Salaam
I. Parente
72'