1. Carlos Miguel
11. Elias Manoel
9. Lewis Morgan
19. Wikelman Carmona
75. Daniel Edelman
48. Ronald Donkor
17. Cameron Harper
6. Kyle Duncan
3. Noah Eile
4. Andres Reyes
12. Dylan Nealis
Ryan Meara
Steven Sserwadda
Bento Estrela
Cory Burke
Dante Vanzeir
Omar Valencia
Julian Hall
Aidan O'Connor
Dennis Gjengaar
18. Roman Celentano
19. Kevin Kelsy
11. Sergio Santos
22. Gerardo Valenzuela
15. Bret Halsey
20. Pavel Bucha
5. Obinna Nwobodo
7. Yuya Kubo
4. Kipp Keller
32. Ian Murphy
91. DeAndre Yedlin
Luca Orellano
Luciano Acosta
Corey Baird
Yamil Asad
Isaiah Foster
Malik Pinto
London Aghedo
Aaron Salem Boupendza
Evan Louro
New York Red Bulls (4-4-2)
1. Carlos Miguel
11. Elias Manoel
74'9. Lewis Morgan
90'19. Wikelman Carmona
75. Daniel Edelman
48. Ronald Donkor
17. Cameron Harper
27'6. Kyle Duncan
3. Noah Eile
4. Andres Reyes
12. Dylan Nealis
Substitutes
Ryan Meara
Steven Sserwadda
Bento Estrela
Cory Burke
90'Dante Vanzeir
74'Omar Valencia
Julian Hall
Aidan O'Connor
Dennis Gjengaar
27'FC Cincinnati (3-4-1-2)
18. Roman Celentano
19. Kevin Kelsy
60'11. Sergio Santos
60'22. Gerardo Valenzuela
46'15. Bret Halsey
46'20. Pavel Bucha
5. Obinna Nwobodo
85'7. Yuya Kubo
4. Kipp Keller
32. Ian Murphy
91. DeAndre Yedlin
Substitutes
Luca Orellano
46'Luciano Acosta
46'Corey Baird
60'Yamil Asad
85'Isaiah Foster
Malik Pinto
London Aghedo
Aaron Salem Boupendza
60'Evan Louro