6. Kyle Duncan
7. Thomas Edwards
10. Patryk Klimala
23. Cristhian Casseres Jr.
27. Sean Davis
3. Amro Tarek
13. Carlos Miguel
5. Andrew Gutman
9. Fbio Roberto Gomes Netto
37. C. Clark
19. W. Carmona
Ryan Meara
Florian Valot
Jason Pendant
Tom Barlow
Omir Fernandez
Frankie Amaya
Sean Nealis
J. Tolkin
Dru Yearwood
5. Gustavo Vallecilla
31. Alvaro Barreal
8. Allan Cruz
9. Brenner da Silva
18. Ronald Matarrita
11. Luciano Acosta
14. Nick Hagglund
25. Kenneth Vermeer
12. Geoff Cameron
7. Yuya Kubo
13. Joseph-Claude Gyau
A. Flanagan
A. Ordonez
Isaac Atanga
Brandon Vazquez
Benjamin Mines
Caleb Stanko
Haris Medunjanin
Przemyslaw Tyton
Kamohelo Mokotjo
New York Red Bulls (4-4-2)
6. Kyle Duncan
7. Thomas Edwards
10. Patryk Klimala
62'23. Cristhian Casseres Jr.
27. Sean Davis
3. Amro Tarek
13. Carlos Miguel
5. Andrew Gutman
62'9. Fbio Roberto Gomes Netto
37. C. Clark
71'19. W. Carmona
71'Substitutes
Ryan Meara
Florian Valot
Jason Pendant
Tom Barlow
62'Omir Fernandez
Frankie Amaya
71'Sean Nealis
J. Tolkin
62'Dru Yearwood
71'FC Cincinnati (4-4-2)
5. Gustavo Vallecilla
31. Alvaro Barreal
8. Allan Cruz
9. Brenner da Silva
89'18. Ronald Matarrita
11. Luciano Acosta
78'14. Nick Hagglund
25. Kenneth Vermeer
12. Geoff Cameron
7. Yuya Kubo
13. Joseph-Claude Gyau
Substitutes
A. Flanagan
A. Ordonez
Isaac Atanga
Brandon Vazquez
89'Benjamin Mines
Caleb Stanko
Haris Medunjanin
78'Przemyslaw Tyton
Kamohelo Mokotjo