24. Tayvon Gray
5. Birk Risa
49. Matt Freese
6. James Sands
7. J. Mijatović
10. Santiago Rodriguez
13. Thiago Martins
17. Hannes Wolf
22. Kevin O'Toole
88. M. Jones
55. Keaton Parks
Andres Perea
Talles Magno
Mitja Ilenič
Axel Agustin Ojeda
Andres Jasson
Adrian Alonso Martínez Batista
Julián Fernández
M. Bakrar
Luis Barraza
75. D. Edelman
31. Carlos Miguel
6. Kyle Duncan
15. Sean Nealis
3. Noah Eile
47. J. Tolkin
17. Cameron Harper
8. Frankie Amaya
9. Lewis Morgan
13. Dante Vanzeir
11. Elias Manoel
Ryan Meara
Andres Reyes
Dylan Nealis
W. Carmona
B. Estrela
Cory Burke
J. Hall
Emil Forsberg
Dennis Gjengaar
64'45'64'45'
64'45'
New York City FC (4-2-3-1)
24. Tayvon Gray
5. Birk Risa
49. Matt Freese
6. James Sands
7. J. Mijatović
58'10. Santiago Rodriguez
72'13. Thiago Martins
17. Hannes Wolf
90'22. Kevin O'Toole
88. M. Jones
73'55. Keaton Parks
Substitutes
Andres Perea
72'Talles Magno
Mitja Ilenič
90'Axel Agustin Ojeda
73'Andres Jasson
Adrian Alonso Martínez Batista
Julián Fernández
M. Bakrar
58'Luis Barraza
New York Red Bulls (4-4-2)
75. D. Edelman
69'31. Carlos Miguel
6. Kyle Duncan
78'15. Sean Nealis
3. Noah Eile
47. J. Tolkin
17. Cameron Harper
46'8. Frankie Amaya
88'9. Lewis Morgan
13. Dante Vanzeir
69'11. Elias Manoel
Substitutes
Ryan Meara
Andres Reyes
88'Dylan Nealis
W. Carmona
46'B. Estrela
Cory Burke
78'J. Hall
Emil Forsberg
69'Dennis Gjengaar
69'