49. Matt Freese
6. James Sands
10. Santiago Rodriguez
12. Strahinja Tanasijevic
16. Alonso Martinez
17. Hannes Wolf
55. Keaton Parks
26. Agustin Ojeda
35. Mitja Ilenic
5. Birk Risa
24. Tayvon Gray
Luis Barraza
Malachi Jones
Justin Haak
Talles Magno
Maxi Moralez
Christian McFarlane
Julian Fernandez
Andres Perea
Jovan Mijatovic
28. Patrick Schulte
6. Darlington Nagbe
9. Juan Hernandez
10. Diego Rossi
17. Christian Ramirez
18. Malte Amundsen
27. Max Arfsten
23. Mohamed Farsi
25. Sean Zawadzki
4. Rudy Camacho
21. Evgen Cheberko
Derrick Jones
Will Sands
S. Lapkes
Aidan Morris
Marino Hinestroza
Yaw Yeboah
Alexandru Matan
C. Mrowka
Steven Moreira
New York City FC (4-4-2)
49. Matt Freese
6. James Sands
10. Santiago Rodriguez
12. Strahinja Tanasijevic
16. Alonso Martinez
57'17. Hannes Wolf
75'55. Keaton Parks
26. Agustin Ojeda
47'35. Mitja Ilenic
5. Birk Risa
24. Tayvon Gray
75'Substitutes
Luis Barraza
Malachi Jones
75'Justin Haak
Talles Magno
Maxi Moralez
57'Christian McFarlane
75'Julian Fernandez
Andres Perea
47'Jovan Mijatovic
Columbus Crew (4-4-2)
28. Patrick Schulte
6. Darlington Nagbe
9. Juan Hernandez
84'10. Diego Rossi
17. Christian Ramirez
18. Malte Amundsen
27. Max Arfsten
84'23. Mohamed Farsi
25. Sean Zawadzki
4. Rudy Camacho
21. Evgen Cheberko
72'Substitutes
Derrick Jones
Will Sands
S. Lapkes
Aidan Morris
72'Marino Hinestroza
Yaw Yeboah
Alexandru Matan
84'C. Mrowka
Steven Moreira
84'