9. M. Bakrar
24. Tayvon Gray
13. Thiago Martins
5. Birk Risa
22. Kevin O'Toole
55. Keaton Parks
11. Julián Fernández
10. Santiago Rodriguez
43. Talles Magno
49. Matt Freese
6. James Sands
Luis Barraza
Justin Haak
Mitja Ilenič
Adrian Alonso Martínez Batista
Matias Pellegrini
Andres Perea
Andres Jasson
Braian Cufre
C. McFarlane
34. Christopher Keith Brady
19. Georgios Koutsias
17. Brian Gutiérrez
24. Robert Jonathan Dean Jr
4. Carlos Terán Díaz
5. Rafael Czichos
3. Daniel Alonso Aceves Patiño
26. Ousmane Doumbia
31. Federico Darío Navarro
21. Fabian Herbers
10. Xherdan Shaqiri
Spencer McNair Richey
Wyatt Omsberg
Maren Haile-Selassie
Mauricio Pineda
Miguel Ángel Navarro Zárate
Ían Jairo Misael Torres Ramírez
Kacper Przybyłko
Kei Ansu Kamara
Arnaud Souquet
New York City FC (4-2-3-1)
9. M. Bakrar
24. Tayvon Gray
60'13. Thiago Martins
5. Birk Risa
22. Kevin O'Toole
55. Keaton Parks
60'11. Julián Fernández
84'10. Santiago Rodriguez
43. Talles Magno
49. Matt Freese
6. James Sands
Substitutes
Luis Barraza
Justin Haak
Mitja Ilenič
60'Adrian Alonso Martínez Batista
Matias Pellegrini
Andres Perea
60'Andres Jasson
84'Braian Cufre
C. McFarlane
Chicago Fire (4-2-3-1)
34. Christopher Keith Brady
19. Georgios Koutsias
65'17. Brian Gutiérrez
24. Robert Jonathan Dean Jr
4. Carlos Terán Díaz
5. Rafael Czichos
3. Daniel Alonso Aceves Patiño
84'26. Ousmane Doumbia
75'31. Federico Darío Navarro
75'21. Fabian Herbers
65'10. Xherdan Shaqiri
Substitutes
Spencer McNair Richey
Wyatt Omsberg
Maren Haile-Selassie
65'Mauricio Pineda
75'Miguel Ángel Navarro Zárate
84'Ían Jairo Misael Torres Ramírez
Kacper Przybyłko
75'Kei Ansu Kamara
65'Arnaud Souquet