0. Matt Freese
5. Birk Risa
22. Kevin O'Toole
6. James Sands
24. Tayvon Gray
55. Keaton Parks
17. Hannes Wolf
16. Adrian Alonso Martínez Batista
13. Thiago Martins
10. Santiago Rodriguez
9. M. Bakrar
Luis Barraza
M. Jones
Justin Haak
Mitja Ilenič
Axel Agustin Ojeda
Andres Jasson
Strahinja Tanasijević
Julián Fernández
Andres Perea
1. Brad Guzan
10. Thiago Almada
11. Brooks Lennon
28. T. Wolff
9. Saba Lobzhanidze
29. Jamal Thiare
8. T. Muyumba
6. Bartosz Slisz
26. C. Wiley
3. Derrick Williams
24. N. Cobb
Joshua Cohen
Luis Abram
L. Brennan
Derrick Etienne
Nicolas Firmino
A. Fortune
Ronald Hernandez
Dax McCarty
Edwin Stiven Mosquera Palacios
New York City FC (4-2-3-1)
0. Matt Freese
5. Birk Risa
22. Kevin O'Toole
6. James Sands
24. Tayvon Gray
81'55. Keaton Parks
17. Hannes Wolf
81'16. Adrian Alonso Martínez Batista
56'13. Thiago Martins
10. Santiago Rodriguez
9. M. Bakrar
Substitutes
Luis Barraza
M. Jones
Justin Haak
Mitja Ilenič
81'Axel Agustin Ojeda
81'Andres Jasson
Strahinja Tanasijević
Julián Fernández
56'Andres Perea
Atlanta United (4-2-3-1)
1. Brad Guzan
10. Thiago Almada
11. Brooks Lennon
28. T. Wolff
56'9. Saba Lobzhanidze
81'29. Jamal Thiare
67'8. T. Muyumba
6. Bartosz Slisz
26. C. Wiley
3. Derrick Williams
24. N. Cobb
Substitutes
Joshua Cohen
Luis Abram
L. Brennan
Derrick Etienne
67'Nicolas Firmino
A. Fortune
81'Ronald Hernandez
Dax McCarty
Edwin Stiven Mosquera Palacios
56'