18. Roman Celentano
4. Nick Hagglund
29. Lukas Engel
21. Matt Miazga
2. Alvas Elvis Powell
14. Brad Smith
20. Pavel Bucha
27. Brian Anunga
10. Evander Ferreira
66. Ender Echenique
9. Kevin Denkey
Kei Ansu Kamara
Evan Louro
Yuya Kubo
Teenage Lingani Hadebe
Gerardo Valenzuela
Stiven Jimenez
Mboma Dem Kenji
Stefan Chirila
Jeffri Gilberto Flores Fernández
49. Matt Freese
24. Tayvon Gray
13. Thiago Martins Thiago Martins
80. Justin Haak
22. Kevin O'Toole
10. Maxi Moralez
21. Aiden Connor O'Neill
8. Andres Perea
17. Hannes Wolf
16. Alonso Martinez
7. Nicolas Fernandez
Tomas Romero
Drew Baiera
Jonathan Shore
Maximo Carrizo
Mitja Ilenic
Julian Fernandez
Strahinja Tanasijevic
Agustin Ojeda
Reid Seymour
FC Cincinnati (5-3-2)
18. Roman Celentano
4. Nick Hagglund
29. Lukas Engel
21. Matt Miazga
2. Alvas Elvis Powell
70'14. Brad Smith
46'20. Pavel Bucha
27. Brian Anunga
71'10. Evander Ferreira
66. Ender Echenique
9. Kevin Denkey
Substitutes
Kei Ansu Kamara
70'Evan Louro
Yuya Kubo
82'Teenage Lingani Hadebe
Gerardo Valenzuela
71'Stiven Jimenez
Mboma Dem Kenji
46'82'Stefan Chirila
Jeffri Gilberto Flores Fernández
New York City FC (4-3-3)
49. Matt Freese
24. Tayvon Gray
13. Thiago Martins Thiago Martins
80. Justin Haak
22. Kevin O'Toole
10. Maxi Moralez
81'21. Aiden Connor O'Neill
8. Andres Perea
43'17. Hannes Wolf
61'16. Alonso Martinez
7. Nicolas Fernandez
Substitutes
Tomas Romero
Drew Baiera
Jonathan Shore
43'Maximo Carrizo
Mitja Ilenic
Julian Fernandez
81'Strahinja Tanasijevic
Agustin Ojeda
61'Reid Seymour