23. Isaac Atanga
5. Gustavo Vallecilla
31. Alvaro Barreal
9. Brenner da Silva
11. Luciano Acosta
14. Nick Hagglund
7. Yuya Kubo
6. Haris Medunjanin
22. Przemyslaw Tyton
2. Edgar Eduardo Castillo Carrillo
12. Geoff Cameron
C. Harris
Kenneth Vermeer
Zico Bailey
Brandon Vazquez
Allan Cruz
Florian Valot
Tyler Blackett
Caleb Stanko
Kamohelo Mokotjo
10. Maxi Moralez
1. Sean Johnson
20. Gudmundur Thorarinsson
7. Alfredo Morales
4. Maxime Chanot
17. Ismael Tajouri-Shradi
19. Jesus Medina
55. Keaton Parks
11. Valentin Castellanos
16. James Sands
2. Chris Gloster
Alexander Callens
Heber
Gedion Zelalem
Malte Amundsen
Tony Rocha
Nicolas Acevedo
Luis Barraza
Talles Magno
A. Jasson
FC Cincinnati (3-4-1-2)
23. Isaac Atanga
5. Gustavo Vallecilla
31. Alvaro Barreal
9. Brenner da Silva
11. Luciano Acosta
14. Nick Hagglund
7. Yuya Kubo
6. Haris Medunjanin
68'22. Przemyslaw Tyton
2. Edgar Eduardo Castillo Carrillo
68'12. Geoff Cameron
77'Substitutes
C. Harris
Kenneth Vermeer
Zico Bailey
Brandon Vazquez
68'Allan Cruz
68'Florian Valot
Tyler Blackett
77'Caleb Stanko
Kamohelo Mokotjo
New York City FC (4-2-3-1)
10. Maxi Moralez
1. Sean Johnson
20. Gudmundur Thorarinsson
84'7. Alfredo Morales
84'4. Maxime Chanot
17. Ismael Tajouri-Shradi
89'19. Jesus Medina
71'55. Keaton Parks
11. Valentin Castellanos
16. James Sands
2. Chris Gloster
46'Substitutes
Alexander Callens
71'Heber
Gedion Zelalem
Malte Amundsen
84'Tony Rocha
89'Nicolas Acevedo
84'Luis Barraza
Talles Magno
A. Jasson
46'