5. Vito Wormgoor
1. Eloy Room
6. Darlington Nagbe
7. Pedro Santos
4. Jonathan Mensah
10. Lucas Zelarayan
31. Steven Moreira
17. Marlon Hairston
22. Derrick Etienne
19. Milton Valenzuela
27. Miguel Berry
Harrison Afful
Bradley Wright-Phillips
Josh Williams
Evan Bush
Erik Hurtado
Saad Abdul-Salaam
Liam Fraser
Aboubacar Keita
Alexandru Matan
24. Kyle Smith
21. Andres Perea
18. Daryl Dike
2. Ruan
9. Chris Mueller
8. Jhegson Mendez
25. Antonio Carlos
6. Robin Jansson
10. Mauricio Pereira
17. Nani
1. Pedro Gallese
Benji Michel
Joseph Dezart
Rodrigo Adrian Schlegel
Silvester van der Water
Mason Stajduhar
Tesho Akindele
Junior Urso
Alexandre Rodrigues da Silva
Emmanuel Mas
Columbus Crew (4-2-3-1)
5. Vito Wormgoor
86'1. Eloy Room
6. Darlington Nagbe
87'7. Pedro Santos
4. Jonathan Mensah
10. Lucas Zelarayan
75'31. Steven Moreira
17. Marlon Hairston
70'22. Derrick Etienne
19. Milton Valenzuela
27. Miguel Berry
Substitutes
Harrison Afful
75'Bradley Wright-Phillips
Josh Williams
86'Evan Bush
Erik Hurtado
Saad Abdul-Salaam
Liam Fraser
70'Aboubacar Keita
87'Alexandru Matan
Orlando City SC (4-2-3-1)
24. Kyle Smith
73'21. Andres Perea
18. Daryl Dike
2. Ruan
9. Chris Mueller
73'8. Jhegson Mendez
46'25. Antonio Carlos
6. Robin Jansson
10. Mauricio Pereira
17. Nani
46'1. Pedro Gallese
Substitutes
Benji Michel
46'Joseph Dezart
Rodrigo Adrian Schlegel
Silvester van der Water
Mason Stajduhar
Tesho Akindele
46'Junior Urso
Alexandre Rodrigues da Silva
73'Emmanuel Mas
73'