28. Patrick Schulte
31. Steven Moreira
25. Sean Zawadzki
18. Malte Amundsen
11. Brooks Lennon
20. Andre Gomes
50. Tarun Karumanchi
33. Gonzalo Tapia
10. Brais Mendez
26. Laurtaro Giaccone
8. Santiago Rodriguez
Nicholas Hagen
Evan Bush
Josef Martinez
Taha Habroune
Jamal Thiare
Amar Sejdic
Dylan Chambost
Cesar Ruvalcaba
Eric Bailly
34. Ethan Horvath
12. Dylan Nealis
26. Tim Parker
56. Matthew Dos Santos
48. Ronald Donkor
15. Adri Mehmeti
37. Mohammed Sofo
17. Cameron Harper
16. Julian Hall
11. Jorge Ruvalcaba
John McCarthy
Devin Padelford
Cade Cowell
Robert Voloder
David Ruiz
Emil Forsberg
Eric Maxim Choupo-Moting
Dennis Nelich
Columbus Crew (4-2-3-1)
28. Patrick Schulte
31. Steven Moreira
25. Sean Zawadzki
18. Malte Amundsen
11. Brooks Lennon
20. Andre Gomes
83'50. Tarun Karumanchi
33. Gonzalo Tapia
71'10. Brais Mendez
26. Laurtaro Giaccone
83'8. Santiago Rodriguez
75'Substitutes
Nicholas Hagen
Evan Bush
Josef Martinez
71'Taha Habroune
75'Jamal Thiare
83'Amar Sejdic
Dylan Chambost
83'Cesar Ruvalcaba
Eric Bailly
New York Red Bulls (4-3-3)
34. Ethan Horvath
12. Dylan Nealis
26. Tim Parker
56. Matthew Dos Santos
66'48. Ronald Donkor
15. Adri Mehmeti
80'37. Mohammed Sofo
17. Cameron Harper
90'16. Julian Hall
80'11. Jorge Ruvalcaba
66'Substitutes
John McCarthy
Devin Padelford
66'Cade Cowell
66'Robert Voloder
David Ruiz
80'Emil Forsberg
Eric Maxim Choupo-Moting
80'Dennis Nelich
90'