28. Patrick Schulte
2. Luis Marcelo Herrera
31. Steven Moreira
18. Malte Amundsen
27. Max Arfsten
7. Dylan Chambost
6. Darlington Nagbe
25. Sean Zawadzki
30. Hugo Picard
19. Jacen Russell-Rowe
26. Lassi Lappalainen
Evan Bush
Amar Sejdic
Rudy Camacho
Derrick Jones
Daniel Gazdag
Taha Habroune
Ibrahim Aliyu
Evgen Cheberko
Cesar Ruvalcaba Perez
23. John McCarthy
12. Dylan Nealis
15. Sean Nealis
42. Alexander Hack
44. Raheem Edwards
4. Gustav Berggren
75. Daniel Edelman
5. Omar Valencia
22. Dennis Gjengaar
13. Eric Maxim Choupo-Moting
10. Emil Forsberg
Carlos Miguel
Tim Parker
Kyle Duncan
Wikelman Carmona
Serge Ngoma
Peter Stroud
Ronald Donkor
Julian Hall
Wiktor Bogacz
66'84'12'66'84'12'
66'84'12'
Columbus Crew (4-3-3)
28. Patrick Schulte
2. Luis Marcelo Herrera
31. Steven Moreira
89'18. Malte Amundsen
27. Max Arfsten
7. Dylan Chambost
82'6. Darlington Nagbe
25. Sean Zawadzki
30. Hugo Picard
19. Jacen Russell-Rowe
61'26. Lassi Lappalainen
46'Substitutes
Evan Bush
Amar Sejdic
Rudy Camacho
Derrick Jones
Daniel Gazdag
46'Taha Habroune
61'Ibrahim Aliyu
82'Evgen Cheberko
Cesar Ruvalcaba Perez
89'New York Red Bulls (3-4-3)
23. John McCarthy
12. Dylan Nealis
74'15. Sean Nealis
42. Alexander Hack
44. Raheem Edwards
59'4. Gustav Berggren
75. Daniel Edelman
5. Omar Valencia
74'22. Dennis Gjengaar
59'13. Eric Maxim Choupo-Moting
74'10. Emil Forsberg
Substitutes
Carlos Miguel
Tim Parker
Kyle Duncan
74'Wikelman Carmona
59'Serge Ngoma
59'Peter Stroud
Ronald Donkor
Julian Hall
74'Wiktor Bogacz
74'