28. Patrick Schulte
31. Steven Moreira
4. Rudy Camacho
18. Malte Amundsen
25. Sean Zawadzki
6. Darlington Nagbe
8. Aidan Morris
14. Yaw Yeboah
19. Jacen Russell-Rowe
10. Diego Rossi
9. Juan Hernandez
Evan Bush
Philip Quinton
Will Sands
Derrick Jones
Marino Hinestroza
Christian Ramirez
Evgen Cheberko
Mohamed Farsi
Max Arfsten
31. Carlos Miguel
6. Kyle Duncan
4. Andrés Felipe Reyes Ambuila
3. Noah Eile
47. J. Tolkin
5. P. Stroud
75. D. Edelman
8. Frankie Amaya
10. Emil Forsberg
9. Lewis Morgan
11. Elias Manoel
Ryan Meara
Cory Burke
W. Carmona
R. Donkor
Dennis Gjengaar
Cameron Harper
R. Mitchell
Dylan Nealis
Sean Nealis
56'67'56'67'
56'67'
Columbus Crew (3-4-2-1)
28. Patrick Schulte
31. Steven Moreira
4. Rudy Camacho
18. Malte Amundsen
25. Sean Zawadzki
79'6. Darlington Nagbe
90'8. Aidan Morris
14. Yaw Yeboah
90'19. Jacen Russell-Rowe
90'10. Diego Rossi
9. Juan Hernandez
90'Substitutes
Evan Bush
Philip Quinton
Will Sands
90'Derrick Jones
90'Marino Hinestroza
90'Christian Ramirez
90'Evgen Cheberko
Mohamed Farsi
79'Max Arfsten
New York Red Bulls (4-4-2)
31. Carlos Miguel
6. Kyle Duncan
4. Andrés Felipe Reyes Ambuila
3. Noah Eile
47. J. Tolkin
5. P. Stroud
75. D. Edelman
8. Frankie Amaya
58'10. Emil Forsberg
9. Lewis Morgan
77'11. Elias Manoel
59'Substitutes
Ryan Meara
Cory Burke
59'W. Carmona
R. Donkor
Dennis Gjengaar
58'Cameron Harper
R. Mitchell
Dylan Nealis
77'Sean Nealis