24. Evan Bush
2. Luis Marcelo Herrera
21. Evgen Cheberko
25. Sean Zawadzki
12. DeJuan Jones
48. Cesar Ruvalcaba Perez
6. Darlington Nagbe
7. Dylan Chambost
13. Aziel Jackson
19. Jacen Russell-Rowe
10. Diego Rossi
Luke Pruter
Lassi Lappalainen
Derrick Jones
Cole Mrowka
Tristan Brown
P. Owens
Amar Sejdic
49. Matt Freese
35. Mitja Ilenic
13. Thiago Martins Thiago Martins
5. Birk Risa
22. Kevin O'Toole
55. Keaton Parks
80. Justin Haak
10. Maxi Moralez
11. Julian Fernandez
9. Monsef Bakrar
17. Hannes Wolf
Alexander Rando
Greg Ranjitsingh
Jonathan Shore
Maximo Carrizo
Strahinja Tanasijevic
Agustin Ojeda
Peter Molinari
Prince Annor Amponsah
Reid Seymour
Columbus Crew (4-3-3)
24. Evan Bush
2. Luis Marcelo Herrera
21. Evgen Cheberko
25. Sean Zawadzki
12. DeJuan Jones
48. Cesar Ruvalcaba Perez
73'6. Darlington Nagbe
7. Dylan Chambost
13. Aziel Jackson
66'19. Jacen Russell-Rowe
10. Diego Rossi
Substitutes
Luke Pruter
Lassi Lappalainen
Derrick Jones
Cole Mrowka
66'Tristan Brown
73'P. Owens
Amar Sejdic
New York City FC (4-3-3)
49. Matt Freese
35. Mitja Ilenic
13. Thiago Martins Thiago Martins
5. Birk Risa
22. Kevin O'Toole
55. Keaton Parks
35'80. Justin Haak
10. Maxi Moralez
11. Julian Fernandez
58'9. Monsef Bakrar
73'17. Hannes Wolf
73'Substitutes
Alexander Rando
Greg Ranjitsingh
Jonathan Shore
35'Maximo Carrizo
73'Strahinja Tanasijevic
Agustin Ojeda
58'Peter Molinari
Prince Annor Amponsah
Reid Seymour
73'