1. Eloy Room
4. Jonathan Mensah
6. Darlington Nagbe
7. Pedro Santos
10. Lucas Zelarayan
14. Waylon Francis
17. Marlon Hairston
26. Saad Abdul-Salaam
20. Alexandru Matan
30. Aboubacar Keita
27. Miguel Berry
Bradley Wright-Phillips
Perry P. Kitchen
Evan Bush
Matt Lampson
Erik Hurtado
Grant Lillard
I. Parente
10. Maxi Moralez
8. Thiago
13. Luis Barraza
26. Nicolas Acevedo
19. Jesus Medina
55. Keaton Parks
11. Valentin Castellanos
20. Gudmundur Thorarinsson
6. Alexander Callens
4. Maxime Chanot
3. Anton Tinnerholm
Santiago Mariano Rodrguez Molina
Tayvon Gray
A. Jasson
Sebastien Ibeagha
Cody Mizell
Malte Amundsen
Tony Rocha
Ismael Tajouri-Shradi
Alfredo Morales
Columbus Crew (4-2-3-1)
1. Eloy Room
4. Jonathan Mensah
6. Darlington Nagbe
7. Pedro Santos
10. Lucas Zelarayan
84'14. Waylon Francis
82'17. Marlon Hairston
82'82'26. Saad Abdul-Salaam
20. Alexandru Matan
59'30. Aboubacar Keita
27. Miguel Berry
63'Substitutes
Bradley Wright-Phillips
63'Perry P. Kitchen
82'Evan Bush
Matt Lampson
Erik Hurtado
59'Grant Lillard
I. Parente
84'New York City FC (4-2-3-1)
10. Maxi Moralez
8. Thiago
13. Luis Barraza
26. Nicolas Acevedo
66'19. Jesus Medina
67'55. Keaton Parks
82'11. Valentin Castellanos
20. Gudmundur Thorarinsson
66'6. Alexander Callens
4. Maxime Chanot
3. Anton Tinnerholm
Substitutes
Santiago Mariano Rodrguez Molina
82'Tayvon Gray
A. Jasson
Sebastien Ibeagha
Cody Mizell
Malte Amundsen
66'Tony Rocha
Ismael Tajouri-Shradi
67'Alfredo Morales
66'