12. Tom Barlow
34. Chris Brady
2. Arnaud Souquet
4. Carlos Teran
5. Rafael Czichos
7. Maren Haile-Selassie
21. Fabian Herbers
8. Chris Mueller
30. Gaston Claudio Gimenez
11. Ariel Lassiter
9. Hugo Cuypers
Tobias Salquist
Spencer Richey
Wyatt Omsberg
Federico Navarro
Kellyn Acosta
Jonathan Dean
Justin Reynolds
Georgios Koutsias
Allan Arigoni
31. Carlos Miguel
12. Dylan Nealis
4. Andres Reyes
3. Noah Eile
47. John Tolkin
17. Cameron Harper
20. Felipe Carballo
75. Daniel Edelman
5. Peter Stroud
9. Lewis Morgan
11. Elias Manoel
Dennis Gjengaar
Ryan Meara
Serge Ngoma
Cory Burke
Dante Vanzeir
Ronald Donkor
Julian Hall
Aidan O'Connor
Chicago Fire (3-5-2)
12. Tom Barlow
72'34. Chris Brady
2. Arnaud Souquet
4. Carlos Teran
53'5. Rafael Czichos
7. Maren Haile-Selassie
21. Fabian Herbers
80'8. Chris Mueller
72'30. Gaston Claudio Gimenez
11. Ariel Lassiter
80'9. Hugo Cuypers
Substitutes
Tobias Salquist
53'Spencer Richey
Wyatt Omsberg
Federico Navarro
80'Kellyn Acosta
72'Jonathan Dean
80'Justin Reynolds
Georgios Koutsias
72'Allan Arigoni
New York Red Bulls (4-4-2)
31. Carlos Miguel
12. Dylan Nealis
4. Andres Reyes
88'3. Noah Eile
47. John Tolkin
17. Cameron Harper
73'20. Felipe Carballo
75. Daniel Edelman
81'5. Peter Stroud
46'9. Lewis Morgan
11. Elias Manoel
46'Substitutes
Dennis Gjengaar
46'Ryan Meara
Serge Ngoma
73'Cory Burke
88'Dante Vanzeir
46'Ronald Donkor
Julian Hall
81'Aidan O'Connor